All News
When Doctors’ Faith Loses to Bureaucratic Power
This article argues that legal and regulatory pressure in Canada is threatening the religious freedom of doctors and faith-based hospitals when institutional beliefs conflict with secular medical law. The piece focuses on a case in British Columbia involving a Catholic hospital that denied on-site access to Medical Assistance in Dying leading a family to sue to compel the facility to allow the procedure. The author claims that forcing medical professionals or institutions to participate in or permit services that contradict their moral convictions undermines freedom of conscience and religious liberty under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
By: Wesley J. Smith
B.C. government struck compromise with assisted dying policy, court hears
This article reports on evidence presented in the British Columbia Supreme Court during a legal dispute over how the province’s assisted-dying policy applies to faith-based hospitals. The court heard that the provincial government reached a “compromise” policy intended to balance access to medical assistance in dying with respect for religious objections by some hospitals, particularly Catholic facilities that do not provide MAID on site. Government witnesses described efforts to ensure patients approved for MAID can receive the procedure without forcing faith-based institutions to act against their beliefs. The testimony also highlighted the role that faith-based facilities, including St. Paul’s Hospital in Vancouver, play in the broader health system and the complexity of maintaining both access and institutional identity.
By: Tara Carman
Exploring Canada’s living tradition of Catholic health care
This article provides an overview of the historical and ongoing tradition of Catholic health care in Canada. It begins by connecting current events, including a legal challenge involving Catholic hospitals in British Columbia, with the deep roots of Catholic healing ministry dating back to early figures such as St. Marguerite Bourgeoys. The article traces how Catholic individuals and religious congregations first established health services long before public systems existed, often providing care in frontier communities and to vulnerable populations. It then explains how these ministries evolved into formal institutions such as hospitals, nursing schools, and care facilities that later operated within publicly funded systems while maintaining a faith-based mission.
By: The B.C. Catholic
HHS Takes Comprehensive Action to Enforce Conscience Rights and Protect Human Life
This press release announces new steps by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services to protect health care workers and institutions who object to certain medical procedures for religious or moral reasons. The agency says it will more actively enforce existing federal laws that allow doctors, nurses, and hospitals to refuse participation in services such as abortion, sterilization, and assisted dying. As part of this effort, the department issued a formal warning to the State of Illinois, arguing that a state law requiring referrals for abortion conflicts with federal conscience protections. The announcement frames these actions as necessary to prevent discrimination against health care providers who choose not to take part in procedures that conflict with their beliefs.
By: HHS Press Office
Families want Canadian provinces to end MAID opt-out policy for faith-based hospitals
Catholic-affiliated hospitals, including St. Paul’s Hospital in Vancouver, prohibit participation in MAID due to religious doctrine, requiring patients who are approved for the procedure to be transferred to non-religious facilities. Patient advocates and families argue that these transfers can cause additional suffering and distress, particularly for patients who are seriously ill or near death. The article highlights cases where patients were moved shortly before dying, prompting legal action by advocacy groups who claim the policy violates patients’ rights and undermines access to publicly funded health care services. Supporters of the policy argue that religious institutions should be permitted to operate in accordance with their beliefs while continuing to provide other essential medical services. The issue is now before the courts.
By: Caroline Barghout
France’s assisted suicide bill and the forced secularization of Catholic healthcare
This article argues that France’s proposed assisted-suicide law would threaten the religious freedom and continued operation of Catholic hospitals, care homes, and nursing homes if they refuse to permit euthanasia or assisted suicide on their premises. The piece states that the bill, already adopted by the French National Assembly and under review in the Senate, would require all healthcare and medico-social institutions, public and private, to allow the practice regardless of their religious identity, with refusal treated as a criminal offence. It further claims that directors of Catholic institutions could face prosecution, fines, and loss of public funding, and presents this as an unprecedented denial of institutional conscience.
By: The Catholic Herald
Euthanasia in France: Catholic Institutions Seriously Threatened
This article reports on concerns among Catholic groups in France over a proposed national euthanasia and assisted-dying law that would require all healthcare institutions to permit euthanasia on their premises. Legal experts and advocates, including the European Centre for Law and Justice, argue that under the draft text, Catholic hospitals, nursing homes, and care facilities could face criminal prosecution, fines, or loss of public funding if they refuse to allow euthanasia. Critics say the bill would force faith-based institutions to act against their moral and religious commitments or face penalties ranging up to prison sentences for directors. Supporters of the Catholic position warn this represents an unprecedented threat to the freedom of religious health-care providers and stress the need to defend institutional conscience rights.
By: FSSPX NEWS